There’s a prevailing belief that only goalkeepers should analyze goalkeeping due to the unique demands of the position. This notion has been reinforced by Joe Hart’s contributions during the World Cup. The former England goalkeeper has emerged as a credible commentator on shot-stopping, offering insights that only someone with his experience can provide. Notable moments include his observations about keepers getting a hand on long-range shots but failing to stop them, noting this isn’t typical, and how a subtle left-sided weight shift contributed to Jordan Pickford being beaten at his near post during the Democratic Republic of the Congo’s goal against England in Atlanta. Hart’s passionate yet clear delivery has made him a valuable asset for the BBC, compensating for their decision to broadcast from home by needing strong analysis.
Roy Keane has often faced criticism as a pundit, yet his performance from ITV’s picturesque New York set has impressed. The former Republic of Ireland captain has maintained his trademark sharp commentary while adopting a calmer demeanor that enhances the viewing experience. Although his analysis may not reach the depth of Emma Hayes, it has certainly exceeded expectations, particularly evident in his dissection of Brazil’s midfield shortcomings in their last-32 match against Japan. Keane’s appearance has also drawn attention, with his well-groomed grey beard and stylish patterned shirt surprising those familiar with his no-nonsense persona.
In the realm of American soccer punditry, Clint Dempsey stands out among a crowd of former players. While figures like Alexi Lalas have long been prominent, Dempsey took a different route after his retirement in 2018, stepping out of the limelight until re-emerging as a commentator for CBS Sports in 2021. Since then, he has proven to be a significant presence on Fox’s World Cup coverage, blending a relaxed style with candid honesty. His commentary mirrors the flair he displayed on the field, contrasting sharply with the more conventional American soccer analysis.
Clarence Seedorf, who retired just prior to the significant rise of European soccer in the United States, has significantly enhanced Fox’s coverage with his presence. Even the charismatic Zlatan Ibrahimovic acknowledged his respect for Seedorf, describing him as one of his idols during their time together on set. The former Netherlands star excels in punditry, engaging in detailed discussions about sequences while seamlessly transitioning to broader evaluations, enriching every segment he is part of—a fitting continuation of his impactful career on the pitch.
Australia
Harry Kewell has shifted his focus to coaching since retiring in 2014, taking on roles in various countries, including England and Japan, albeit with limited success. Therefore, his transition to a pundit role on SBS’s World Cup panel was unexpected. Kewell quickly captured the local audience’s attention, notably responding to US analyst Mike Grella’s disparaging remarks about Australia prior to the tournament. His analyses have proven to be insightful and thought-provoking, drawing on his coaching experience rather than merely relying on his status as a former player, providing a refreshing perspective amid the often nationalistic rhetoric surrounding the Socceroos.
Kevin-Prince Boateng’s role as a pundit on Australian television during the World Cup raised eyebrows initially. However, his presence makes sense as he has been residing in Australia since his retirement and is currently coaching the national six-a-side team. Sharing a panel with fellow former players, including Lydia Williams and Tommy Oar, Boateng adds an international dynamic to the discussions. His forthright style has allowed him to deliver unvarnished opinions throughout the tournament, particularly during Ghana’s matches, setting him apart from his colleagues.
- World Cup 2026
- World Cup
- Sport TV
- Television
- ITV1
- BBC
- BBC One
- features
